Character of the Week #3 Voting Group D


 Topic: Character of the Week #3 Voting Group D
Users reading this topic: There are no members reading this topic.
  Posted on January 17, 2013 12:32
CotYAccount
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Pyro's Slave

Posts: 446
Joined on:
December 27, 2012
#1
Welcome to the first Week trial of Character of the Year. The point of this contest. The purpose of this contest is to decide who has made the best character within a Year of work, by requiring criticisms for our fellow Naruto-Boards members, and of course improve ourselves in character making and have fun. This is a voting topic so all you have to do is vote... respecting the rules of course.

Read the voting rules! It's very easy to break a rule unwillingly!

Voting Rules and Mode of Voting:
Your votes must mention something about each character. (Eg: I like how character x deals a lot of damage and how character y has great defensive...)
You must specify why you consider the character you vote better than the other two character(s). (Eg: I consider that character x is better, because unlike the other characters, he deals an average amount of damage with simple costs, keeping up with his flow, but the other two have messy high amount of damage that are just an excuse to make the character original)
Your decision may not be based solely on pictures. (Eg of what you should not do:
#3 character has better pictures than the other two. Their pictures are LQ and lame. #3 is for me)
If you mention something about the balance of a character, you must exemplify why you consider that character.(Eg: First character is much better than the second because he is balanced. Unlike 2nd character that can go invulnerable for 5 turns in a row, this character is simply awesome, he just deals the right amount of damage and has the right amount of defense.)
If you mention something about the flow of a character, you must exemplify the flow of the character.(Eg: I prefer first character's flow because you can use 1st and 2nd skill in order to create a gigantic amount of defense and then use 3rd skill in order to succesfully stun the opponent for a great amount of turns. Anyway, 2nd character lacks any kind of flow, which I dislike. All that character's skill are randomly thought effects)
Originality may not be used as a reason to vote, but it can still be mentioned in votes. (Eg of what to not do: This character is original. VOTE VOTE VOTE #3 VOTE!!
Oversimplified/Overcomplicated character may be used as a reason, as long as you explain why the character is too complicated or too simple. (Eg: First character is too simple, because it only has simple and plain effects, while the second character is too complicated, because it has too many effects that are placed there randomly)
The design of the template does not count if that's the sole reason you vote for one character. The pictures will also count in this category, if mentioned, so they won't count as something else if mentioned in the vote.
•You may only vote for one character.
•You may not vote for yourself, unless the group contains only your character. You won't need to give any reasonings if they are your characters.
•You may not empty quote or copy any of the votes already given or say in your vote, I agree with person x.
•You may not vote if your post count is under 500 posts.
•You may not vote if your account is not two months old.


~Now that everything has been said:~

Entry #1


Entry #2


Entry #3


Entry #4
  Posted on January 17, 2013 23:44
pursin
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
N-A Illuminati

Posts: 6720
Joined on:
July 19, 2007
#2
Character number 1.
I love the originality of his character. The potions. Switch. Everything.
The flow is also amazing, he even managed to make potions involve the flow.
The attack power of the 1st skill is all ddetermined by what's going on with ththe other skills.
Although, the fact that the max damage output of it is 40 piercing damage tthat can't be reduced for 1 specific and no cooldown is a bit, I don't really mind it because of all of the conditions that must be met first.
I particularly like how switch and party invite work to protect and boost damage.
I've wanted to make love with this character eever since I first read it.

Character number two.
Oh... a goku... great.
I was originally going to say "SERIOUSLY, 15 DAMAGE DRAGON FIST!?"
But, now that I read the entire character I believe he's overall OP.
All of the cooldowns make up for the HUGE damage output, but you could insta-kill someone for a random energy after Kamehameha. Yes the health must be below 25, but if you saved your ki, that could be easily achived, especially if you have other heavy hitters on the team.
The flow and how the second and third skill eeffect dragon fist is magnificent and the pics are great for dbz.
I love this character but the dbz logic is off the scale.

Entry number three.
First skill already got me. The magnet effect is amazing. I haven't even fi ished reading it and I love it.
I would just like to know, in the case of an aoe, would they take all that damage? Becayse let's say there is a 35 aoe special damge kinda like 1010 S old skill. That's an insta kill right there e.e
On to the rest of it.
The electrical charges are nice and the lighting defense is awesome. The flow with the charges is great with railgun but i wish the lightning defense affected it in some wway considering they're removed after use.
I'm guessing the lighting ddefense is still llike DD so it blocks AND deals damage, so i think the second skill sshould have a cooldown as to she could just renew it EVERY turn and partly become invisible if she has enough charges. I would just keep using the 4th and 2nd skill. Maybe the 1st when I got the cchance. Railgun wouldn't even be necessary in this instance
I liked the concept oof this character but it probably could have been balanced just a bit better.
Pics could be better.
MISREAD
Didn't realise that the 22nd and 4th skill were passive e.e
Makes the character ALOT better.

NUMBER FOUR
With the 1st skill, again I have the AOE question. Will it be dealt 105 damage, or just the 35 (example from the other character)
That 2nd skill ks nice and helpful. preve ts a ddeath. Prevents stuns, and gives double damage+
I think the 3rd skill is UP. 1st of all I'm not a fan of offensive skills with limited uses (especially one use)
Although the boost from the 2nd skill ccould make iit quite devastating, the way it doesn't even deal damage when aanother skill is used bothers me. The pics are nice HQ stuff. The flow bebetween the skills could be much bbetter.

FINAL
the 2nd and 3rd character are on the same level for me and the 4th character doesn't compare. However i find the 1st character to be better than them all in balance and is in comparison equal with originality. It's flow is great and everything about he character is magnificent.
I know I said I didn't want a SAO character to win but my vote goes for the first.

FINAL EDIT:
Now that I read the Misaka right she ggets my vote. I like the concept bbehind her a bit more than than the fifirst character and is a monolith compared to the goku. I still think the pics could be better but it is comparable to the 1st character now and stands slightly higher than iit in my opinion.
  Posted on January 18, 2013 14:19
CotYAccount
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Pyro's Slave

Posts: 446
Joined on:
December 27, 2012
#3
Third character advances, stop voting.