Youtube Debate. Who's right, who's wrong?

Users reading this topic: There are no members reading this topic.

Posted on September 11, 2012 20:20

gerronix11
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Sannin

Posts: 3818
Joined on:
August 14, 2008

Ok, here's the scenario. I guess everyone if not, most of us know what Britain's got talent is.? Ok. So this girl age, 6 or 7 years old performed in front of the judges by dancing. One of the judges who's called Pier then started to press the buzzer since the dancing isn't as professional. This then makes the little girl cry who walked out getting her confidence squashed. If you want to watch the actual video,

click this.

Two people then debates, Person B and C. Who's right, who's wrong?

Person A: I like that some people here are like "piers is such a douche" so, every little kid that goes on the show should never get an X? Piers didn't like it, so he pressed the buzzer, that's what he is supposed to do, idiots.

Person B: Yes. They should never get an X. An X represents "I'd had enough of your shitty performance. Get the fuck out". Is it right to imply that to a child? A child's confidence can build up little by little, but once its gone, its hard to get it back. Not getting an X doesn't mean she will have to get through. he could have atleast let her finish and say No nicely and probably a little compliment so she won't feel ashamed.

Person C: And that's how you raise your kids to be insufferable douchebags.
What the fuck else did the kid expect on a show like this? I hope you never have kids.

Person B: Yeah, because when you have a kid, or if you already have one, you would let them put up with it themselves when this happened to them. How ignorant of you not to know that children under the age of 13 doesn't have as much self-esteem as grown-ups have. And nothing really was wrong with what she did to get a buzzer. She was dancing probably as good as average kids does. And you can already see in Pier's face that he regretted doing that so really, we already know who's wrong.

Person C: Then it's the parents' fault for letting their kid on the show, knowing full well how it's like.
So you're suggesting the show's format be changed because a little girl shouldn't be saddened by it?
It's people like you who feel the need to sugarcoat society who fuck up the future by filling it up with insufferable, delusional douchebags who can't admit to fucking up when they do.
Blame the parents, not the world around them, dumbass.

Person B: I bet not even her Mum or any member of her family knew that she will get a buzz since she's not doing anything stupid like other contestants do who totally deserved it. And I never said the format should be changed. All I'm saying is Pier should know how a person feels regardless of their age and their situation their in. There's always a right time for a child to manage on her own at situations like this. Is it hard to put this little things in your tiny brain? Oh wait, you don't have one.

Posted on September 11, 2012 20:26

leejackson
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Genin

Posts: 107
Joined on:
April 24, 2010

DAYUM THAT OLD MAN IS A DOUCHE

-.::Ryoku-Chat::.-.::Ryoku-Thread::.-.::Ryoku-Recruitment::.-

Posted on September 11, 2012 20:27

rasan2kun
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Jounin

Posts: 1594
Joined on:
November 24, 2010

Person A ran away apparently D:
well i agree with person B, and i think person C is just trying to be negative on youtube just cause he has nothing better to do
hope that makes some sense :suspicious

21-0~Whose Next ?~
"Do not underestimate the visual prowess of the Uchiha,girl."
Obessesed with Tobi,WTF!
||Zoro's Asmv|||Ace's Asmv|||The Courage To Dream|||UsoppVsLuffy Asmv
||Saddest Asmv||KonanVsTobi||
"Thanks to me you were saved too, you should be thankful."

Posted on September 11, 2012 20:30

trttrfggffffe
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Sannin

Posts: 3648
Joined on:
December 27, 2009

That's life...............................

trttrfggffffe (-Màstêr rônx-)

Death Dream

Posted on September 11, 2012 20:41

Shinsterp
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Academy Student

Posts: 11
Joined on:
August 20, 2012

I mostly believe person C is right.
That is a serious contest. A 6-year old, unprepared girl had nothing to do in that place.

Edit: Indeed, he could have waited until she was finished just for the sake of kindness, but still.

Sig and avy by Teri
shin-1.png?t=1354044231

Posted on February 9, 2013 05:28

DylanHolder
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Academy Student

Posts: 0
Joined on:
February 9, 2013

Youcanaskanyone: New social network where you can ask questions, tell your side of the story, and have the person you have issues with tell their side of the story, and let the world decide who's right! Check it out at: http://www.youaskanyone.com/

Posted on February 9, 2013 16:09

EvanGrant
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Sannin

Posts: 4799
Joined on:
February 21, 2007

Person C. This is a contest and the judges can't have bias just because it's a little kid. If so, everyone would just put their little kids on the show and it would become a joke. As "cute" as it is, nobody came to see a little kid try their interpretation of dance. They came to see people with actual talent, hence the name "Britain's Got Talent."

Sig by Wild_Thing_00

Posted on February 10, 2013 20:43

gerronix11
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Sannin

Posts: 3818
Joined on:
August 14, 2008

EvanGrant wrote:

seems like you don't get the situation. Not buzzing off a contestant doesn't mean they'll let them through the next round. Its just coping with the situation the child is in.

Posted on February 11, 2013 11:47

EvanGrant
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Sannin

Posts: 4799
Joined on:
February 21, 2007

gerronix11 wrote:

EvanGrant wrote:

seems like you don't get the situation. Not buzzing off a contestant doesn't mean they'll let them through the next round. Its just coping with the situation the child is in.

Yes I know how the game show works. However there is rarely a circumstance where someone gets buzzed and they still get enough votes to go to the next round.

But what I was saying is that Piers saw she didn't have talent, so he buzzed her, and there's nothing wrong with that. He was just doing his job.

Sig by Wild_Thing_00

Posted on February 11, 2013 17:19

gerronix11
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Sannin

Posts: 3818
Joined on:
August 14, 2008

#10

EvanGrant wrote:

gerronix11 wrote:

EvanGrant wrote:

seems like you don't get the situation. Not buzzing off a contestant doesn't mean they'll let them through the next round. Its just coping with the situation the child is in.

first off, its a talent show. Not game show.

Secondly, its a kid. People should learn how to cope and to act in certain circumstances. And to do that is part of a judge's job.

You know Simon right? The other judge. He's known for his strict opinions and truthful personality which often leads people into tears and embarrassment. Even that so, he knows how to act on certain situations which is the reason why you won't see him buzzing off the kid.

Its just like how you wouldn't swear around the room with 5-10 year old kids around you, or sleep inside the church or mess around with strangers in public or copy somebody's paper in an exam. Its called coping with the situation.

Youtube Debate. Who's right, who's wrong?

Youtube Debate. Who's right, who's wrong?

WHO'S ONLINE