Team Renegade vs Team Neomorphis [round 1 of NB got Gfx-Talent]


 Topic: Team Renegade vs Team Neomorphis [round 1 of NB got Gfx-Talent]
Users reading this topic: There are no members reading this topic.
  Posted on March 17, 2010 12:26
Fallen_Moon
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Jounin

Posts: 1041
Joined on:
March 1, 2009
#1
This is one of the first battles of NB got Gfx-Talent.
The Teams participating in this battle are Team Renegade and Team Neomorphis
renegadegfxbanner.png 34ilder.jpg
Team Renegade________________________vs__________Team Neomorphis

Good luck to both teams n_n
Just post which work you like the most =]

Rules
-Votes will be counted by posts
-You must have 200 or more posts to vote
-You are not allowed to vote for your own team( but you can still vote for the opponents if you want)
-You can only vote once and only for 1 entry
-Voting will be opened for 1 day


Entries of Team Renegade(Theme was photo-manipulation):

entry1:
2uom5hy.png

entry2:
Photomanipulation.png
stock used: stock1 stock2 stock3 stock4 stock5

entry 3:
naturalnature.png

entry4:
eye.png


Entries of Team Neomorphis(Theme was C4D's):

entry5:
efqyag.jpg

entry6:
11sh5pw.jpg

entry7:
4426042926_281b13c959_o.png

entry8:
c4ds.png?t=1268687826

entry9:
bjadli.jpg

entry10:
2vs1zwp.jpg


Judges Opinion:
Sandmanxx23:
I believe that Team Neomorphis won this contest.

Let me start by saying all the entries were good, some better than others. However for Team Renegade, I believe entry #2 was the best. It was the cleanest, crispest one out of all the entrys for their team.

Um, I'll try to give a little CnC for all the tags for Team Renegade.

Entry 1
Great idea, however, the blending by the head of the lion could of been crisper, and the background needed some more spazz to it.

Entry 2
Answered above. I liked this one.

Entry 3
Um, this one had a good idea as well. However, the flower looked sort of messy, it was also sort of oversized. The colors needed some work. Background was nice, nice use of blur.

Entry 4
Lol, this entry made me lol. It is very crisp and clean, I really liked this one as well.

Now for Team Neomorphis. I thought entry number 4 for Neomorphis was the best one. The colors were beautiful, and everything was crisp.

Now for their CnC.

Entry 5
I liked this one, it had a good first impression to it. The lighting is nice, and the font fits in well.

Entry 6
I liked this one as well. It has a nice look to it. Though somewhat simple.

Entry 7
It was a little too small, the font looks very good though. The texture all works together.

Entry 8
Best, I really liked it.

Entry 9
This one is also very nice, I love the idea in it and the shading of everything.

Entry 10
This one was really simple and plain, lol. Sorry.

So, thats what about. Very good job both teams, but a congrats to Team Neomorphis.


Fallen_Moon:
I will start with Team Renegade.
Entry1: Its nice but for my taste the compo is just too simple, it could also need some more work on the transition between tiger and flames, but i like how the flames have the outline of the tiger body, the background is too blurry for my taste and doesn't show much variety.
Entry2: I have to agree with Sand, this entry is really the best entry of Team Renegade. The main concept is good and the execution as well, there are only 2 things i would really criticize about this work. The girls dress could be cut out better at some areas and at some areas the lightning is kinda off for example the wolf on the very right has a different light source like the main piece.
entry3:the main concept is ok but the execution is just too sloppy, also i can't point out a main lightsource that applies to the body and the flowerhead as well, as for the background, good use of blurring to create depth, although at some areas the blurring seems too much.
entry4:The main concept is just too simple, also i am not a fan of the colors.

Now to Team Neomoprphis:
entry5:I think the main concept had some potential, would had wished to see more play with the mirrors, the main issue of this work is that the lighttransition could really need more work, also the text takes away too much from the focal, the reflection effect is nice.
entry6:colors are good, but the whole piece looks kinda random with those the background that doesn't seem to interact with c4d at all and the messy c4d itself.
entry7:the text kills it really, the overall compo could need more structure, some parts look to over-sharpened, also to me the negative space doesn't support the tag too well.
entry8:concept is ok but the execution could need work, really sloppy at some parts especially at the transition between c4d's and human body, also the splatters are too sharp and are just creating messiness. The thing is that there are many effects that doesn't seem to work too well with each other.
entry9:its too bright, its hard to see the details, also colors are too monotone, they could be more vibrant, the compo itself could need more structure.
entry10:first symmetry tag i saw in this contest, colors are nice the concept and the compo are quite simple, but they would work if there would had been more work on lightning

All in all i think both teams did a good job and i would say that if i look at the teams as one there would be a draw, but the work which pop out the most to me is entry2 of Team Renegade, so i would say Team Renegade did the better job in this round =O
  Posted on March 17, 2010 12:42
-Inn0c3ncE-
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Genin

Posts: 51
Joined on:
March 10, 2010
#2
fcuk the entry #10 .. -.- It was like "Blue Background, C4D, mirror, then blur .. How dumb ..
(That was just my opinion, if I offended someone, sorry)
- Banned from the Naruto-Boards' forums -
  Posted on March 17, 2010 12:44
-EliteVolocity-
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Jounin

Posts: 1837
Joined on:
October 23, 2009
#3
No point but i say 5th
ambitiontest01.png Tag.gif
  Posted on March 17, 2010 12:50
Laziest
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Special Jounin

Posts: 759
Joined on:
March 8, 2010
#4
That really cool

_lazy__by_MenInASuitcase.gif
  Posted on March 17, 2010 16:31
omninight14
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Jounin

Posts: 1867
Joined on:
January 23, 2007
#5
I'm torn between the 2nd, and the 8th entry, based on my first impressions and the judges' opinions.

As a final decision, I'll go with Entry #2, and team Renegade
sp2.png
^Click it, yo.
  Posted on March 17, 2010 17:27
Limba
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Special Jounin

Posts: 515
Joined on:
September 28, 2007
#6
i like entry 5
Sig4.jpg
palinay49 wrote:
Don't post if u are not romanian.......................
am 13 ani si ma masturbez regulat de 6 luni si vreu sa ma las dar nu pot si ce ar trebui sa fac?
----Laughing out my nose


please click.i need only 10 clicks at all
  Posted on March 17, 2010 17:44
InSoMaNiAc
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Sannin

Posts: 3696
Joined on:
August 14, 2008
#7
Entry 2 wins it for me :embarressed
dA Youtube Showcase(Not been updated in like forevah) Shop

"That's envy my dear, there's a little bit of envy in the best of us". ~ Elwood ( Harvey,1950)

I used to be active on N-B , but then I took an arrow to the knee

Retired / Inactive / Watching You
  Posted on March 17, 2010 20:14
miskos3
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Sannin

Posts: 3721
Joined on:
October 27, 2007
#8
I really liked entry #2 and #8, but I'll go with second one.
So yeah, I vote for #2.
Tobs was here!
miskostag.png
Ava by Sori ;D
  Posted on March 17, 2010 21:07
Vaprc
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Jounin

Posts: 1072
Joined on:
September 2, 2007
#9
I vote in number 5 :amused
A censura aqui é maior que na própria televisão, adeus.

adeus.
  Posted on March 17, 2010 21:15
Hiei520
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Jounin

Posts: 1339
Joined on:
February 5, 2009
#10
I vote in number 6
tumblr_luktco7AFI1qle2ioo1_500.gif
CHAMAS NEGRAS MORTAIS -A song say goodbye Nothing In My Way PLACEBO É MEU ESCUDO
sektor - meu patrao ----------------------- Shad - meu tio
moda - meu amigao ---------------------- Iper - Aluno
killlua - morreD)D)D)D)
lynank - apanhei sad4
JEFINHO - SIM SENHOR!!!!!
PARA SEMPRE SUN>><<><> XAT SUN
  Posted on March 17, 2010 21:34
DachiVale
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Genin

Posts: 73
Joined on:
March 2, 2010
#11
I would vote 5 or 6, I like both actualy, not sure if that matters if I vote 5 or 6, but if I have to chose 1 of those, then I would say tag 5... it shows just a little more appeal to me, it has a nice dept, the text is pretty good and the placement of all elements is also pretty good, although the compo imo is a bit to centered... ;)

oops, sorry, just read I cant vote, although my design knowledge is probably more then most, I dont have 200 plus post count... and probably wont get that any time soon, since there is not alot that I can post on... :S
Class: 'High' Intermediate ~~ Member of: Team Illustradoz
2010Dachi-K-KOF-VectorandMorecopy.png
macpyp.jpg
  Posted on March 17, 2010 22:20
Akatsunara
Rank: moderator

Forum Rank:
ANBU

Posts: 8687
Joined on:
January 24, 2009
#12
I vote in the #2, it's the most complete one imo. However, the #1 was soo close ;D
  Posted on March 17, 2010 22:50
!Hatake
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Chuunin

Posts: 401
Joined on:
December 18, 2009
#13
i vote number 5 :amused
Lorwyn Gikei - 2010
28741a8.png




  Posted on March 17, 2010 22:50
SrLopz
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Jounin

Posts: 1409
Joined on:
July 26, 2009
#14
number 5 is best
BahaSignature.png
Sing By Marcos_hyuga
Amanda Te Amo
Internacional S2
:embarressed
  Posted on March 17, 2010 22:57
LucasDiaz
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Special Jounin

Posts: 553
Joined on:
November 9, 2007
#15
i vote number 5 :rolleyes
Lucs.png
Sig by Ulquiorra_san , avy by kgb_lex
| FrY Leader | This is the fraternity , this is a family | |Ratazana's F.C|
| gift by Lupe,Ero ~TnX |