Cear View


 Topic: Cear View
Users reading this topic: There are no members reading this topic.
  Posted on August 27, 2008 11:28
Takeru89
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Kage

Posts: 3500
Joined on:
June 2, 2007
#1

Cear View


The hardest pain needs to be broken,
rivers of sorrow have to dry,
cold wind is made of oaken,
fire is ment to shine,
earths are bound to quake,
ore has to age,
hope is sake,
blinding
truth.
  Posted on August 27, 2008 11:30
hbk268
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Kage

Posts: 4756
Joined on:
August 12, 2007
#2
7.5 outa 8...too short
Believe In The Leaf//

  Posted on August 27, 2008 16:04
chem5
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Special Jounin

Posts: 757
Joined on:
August 14, 2007
#3
Decent, declining syllables is a nice idea, overall didn't pull it together enough.

"Cold wind is made of oaken" just felt out of place completely, as I'm sure you had a mental image of what you were referencing..some metaphor you were shooting for, but it didn't transition through for me as well as some of the rest.

Another suggestion I might make...you're going to need to be quite a bit more profound with a poem of that limited size. A small quick poem can often be favored over a larger poem for the simple fact that it is more to the point, but is also more difficult to achieve success with. The lesser amount of time you have with the reader means you have to really hit them with stunning imagery and deep symbolism right from the start, and keep it at a high level for the short amount of time you have their attention.

Unfortunately, I don't think you reached that level, as your lines were good, but none of them were incredibly stunning. Some were close, but others fell flat. "Rivers of sorrow have to dry" just felt cliche and overdone, while "earths are bound to quake" actually was solid.

Overall, a good attempt especially for the amount of room you had to work with, but just was short of pulling it together. Look forward to seeing your next piece.
Quote by blindyful
Chemmy Chemster Chemmeh Chemed Chemified El'chemo Chemwem SuperChem Chemers Chemdaman Chem>ChEmErS Chemerster Chemsy C5 Chemsay Chemzorz LordChem Chemtron Chemonic Chemeon Chemzard Chemcom Chemstreet GossipinChem CHEMTODAY Chemtimes Chemchews DarkFireChem RedChem Chemroth Chemture Chemccx Chemsama Chemkun Chemchan Chemv Cheman Chemgakure Chemrachi MissChem Chemsoup..............Hello ._.

Clan page
Clan Profile Page
Mostri Requirement page
  Posted on August 27, 2008 17:40
Takeru89
Rank: member

Forum Rank:
Kage

Posts: 3500
Joined on:
June 2, 2007
#4
Quote by chem5
Decent, declining syllables is a nice idea, overall didn't pull it together enough.

"Cold wind is made of oaken" just felt out of place completely, as I'm sure you had a mental image of what you were referencing..some metaphor you were shooting for, but it didn't transition through for me as well as some of the rest.

Another suggestion I might make...you're going to need to be quite a bit more profound with a poem of that limited size. A small quick poem can often be favored over a larger poem for the simple fact that it is more to the point, but is also more difficult to achieve success with. The lesser amount of time you have with the reader means you have to really hit them with stunning imagery and deep symbolism right from the start, and keep it at a high level for the short amount of time you have their attention.

Unfortunately, I don't think you reached that level, as your lines were good, but none of them were incredibly stunning. Some were close, but others fell flat. "Rivers of sorrow have to dry" just felt cliche and overdone, while "earths are bound to quake" actually was solid.

Overall, a good attempt especially for the amount of room you had to work with, but just was short of pulling it together. Look forward to seeing your next piece.


thanks for taking some of your time and thinking about my poem
i will remind your words when i write my next poem n_n